Addressing the problem of outside assistance in pre-sessional writing assessments

Westbrook, Carolyn and Holt, Peter Stephen (2015) Addressing the problem of outside assistance in pre-sessional writing assessments. Journal of English for Academic Purposes, 18 . pp. 78-83. ISSN 1475-1585

Full text not available from this repository. (Request a copy)


Reading-into-writing assessments on pre-sessional language programmes typically employ either a take-home essay format with a substantial reading component or an exam-based writing task with a reading component of perhaps only one or two pages. While both approaches reflect a welcome trend towards more integrative models of validity for the assessment of academic writing, their usefulness may nevertheless be undermined by their task design. The apparent recent increase in the activity of ghost writers, often facilitated by various technological means, can cast sufficient doubt over the authorship of take-home essays to invalidate the assessment. The exam-based task, on the other hand, may suffer from construct under-representation (Messick, 1996: 6) since its limited reading component requires little or no expeditious reading (Weir and Urquhart, 1998: 98–100) of the longer texts commonly associated with university study. This article describes a response to these validity issues in the form of an open-book-exam, concluding that the processing of longer texts outside the exam room combined with the security of a written response under exam conditions can reduce the time spent on dealing with plagiarism cases arising from outside assistance while at the same time demonstrating some positive washback on learning (Messick, 1996: 6) in terms of increased engagement with the source texts used.
Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: Washback; Plagiarism; Integrated testing; Ghost writing; Learning
Divisions: School of Languages
Depositing User: Peter Stephen Holt
Date Deposited: 16 Jun 2015 14:27
Last Modified: 02 Aug 2019 16:24

Actions (login required)

View Item
View Item